An upheaval is underway in the nation’s electricity sector, and Virginia is ground zero. As the data center capital of the world, the state faces surging demand, ballooning utility bills, and a bottlenecked grid — all challenges that policymakers are navigating while maintaining a legally mandated course toward carbon neutrality.
Now, the state is poised to become the first in the nation to quantify and examine ways to reduce waste on the electric grid — a potentially monumental move toward reining in rates and speeding the clean energy transition. Maximizing usage of our existing network of power lines and related infrastructure, backers say, could also help close the gap between the public interest and that of investor-owned utilities.
House Bill 434 would direct Appalachian Power Co. and Dominion Energy, the state’s two predominant vertically integrated utilities, to gather and report detailed data on their grid utilization. The measure won final approval from Virginia’s Democratic-controlled legislature this week and now heads to the desk of Gov. Abigail Spanberger — a Democrat whose victory in November was fueled in part by anxiety over rising electricity costs. As one of the earliest proposals Spanberger offered after her election to address energy affordability, the bill looks certain to become law.
Many experts say the information the measure would require is itself meaningful: Utilities have long resisted gathering and reporting such metrics, in part because doing so could hurt their case to build out more infrastructure that pads their bottom lines.
But advocates for HB 434 say its real impact could come after the utilization data has been reviewed by regulators, who must then establish a timeline for utilities to optimize grid usage. The bill directs officials to give special consideration to “non-wires alternatives” like batteries and line sensors.
“The fact that Virginia became the first state to introduce this sort of legislation is pretty significant,” said Charles Hua, the founder and executive director of PowerLines, a nonprofit that aims to lower utility bills and supports HB 434. “But this would just be the first step of a long journey.”
Lowering rates through the “denominator effect”
The legislation is premised on an incredible reality: Roughly half the electric grid goes unused about 99% of the time. Poles, wires, substations, and other components are built out to deliver electrons during periods of maximum demand, such as during the recent cold snap brought on by Winter Storm Fern. But those peak events are rare.
“This is where this conversation has been stuck for 20 years,” said Pier LaFarge, the co-founder and CEO of Sparkfund, which helps utilities deploy and manage distributed energy sources. “We’ve built the grid to peak … then said, ‘How much space is left?’ But what’s amazing is, the grid only is at peak 50 to 200 hours a year out of 3,760.”
Another factor is that some kilowatt-hours are lost as they travel from the point of generation to the customer, especially along lower-voltage AC distribution lines.
“Local poles and wires, that is, the distribution grid, is really not that efficient,” Hua said. “But you never would really know, because there’s not a ton of transparency around spending.”
HB 434 would prompt Appalachian Power and Dominion to examine and quantify these utilization gaps and inefficiencies as part of a regulatory proceeding this fall. The state’s utilities commission would then review and approve that data and direct the companies to increase grid utilization.
The measure requires regulators to evaluate key technologies — from energy storage to synchronous condensers, which reduce line loss — to improve use of the grid. It also opens the door for regulators to weigh grid utilization when considering utility proposals to instead expand their infrastructure.
In theory, these steps should lead to lower rates for customers. “Electricity rates are a math equation,” Hua said, where the top of the fraction is the cost of grid infrastructure, among other investments, and the bottom half is the number of kilowatt-hours sold.
Increasing grid utilization divides the fixed cost of the poles and wires — roughly the same numerator — by more electrons, a much higher denominator. “Therefore, you’re lowering the per-unit price of electricity,” Hua said, “and you’re lowering utility bills for all consumers.”
Great Job Elizabeth Ouzts & the Team @ Canary Media for sharing this story.
